Forty-six different Saint Joseph's athletes have combined to earn a total of
68 All-America honors in the history of Monks athletics: 

Sport Name Year(s) Award
M. Basketball John Alexander 1974 1974 NAIA All-American Honorable Mention
M. Basketball Mike Johnston 1974 1974 NAIA All-American Honorable Mention
M. Basketball Jeff Creech 1985, 1986 '85 NAIA Hon. Mention, '86 NAIA Hon. Mention, NABC 2nd Team, Kodak 3rd Team
Baseball Bill Mucci 1985 1985 NAIA Honorable Mention 
Baseball Kevin Fitzgerald 1986 1986 NAIA Honorable Mention 
Baseball Arlo Pike 1986 1986 NAIA Honorable Mention
Cross Country George Bockus 1987 1987 All-American 
W. Basketball Carolyn Brooks 1988 1988 NAIA Honorable Mention, Kodak All-American All-District 
Cross Country Scott Roberts 1988 1988 All-American
W. Basketball Kendra Coates 1991 1991 NAIA All-American, 1991 Bill Bradley Scholastic All-American 
Baseball Leon Renaud 1990, 1991, 1992 1990 NAIA All-American, 1991 NAIA All-American, 1992 NAIA All-American 
M. Basketball Greg Collymore 1991, 1993 1991 NAIA Honorable Mention, 1993 NAIA Honorable Mention 
W. Soccer Kelly Wood 1993  
M. Basketball Jamie Header 1993 1993 NAIA Honorable Mention 
M. Basketball Steve Schuler 1993, 1994 1993 NAIA Honorable Mention, 1994 NAIA Honorable Mention
W. Basketball Sharon Rines 1993, 1994 1993 Kodak All-American, 1994 Kodak All-American
Softball Dani Waterman 1994  
Volleyball Karen Heslin 1995  
W. Basketball Danielle Bouchard 1995 1995 NAIA 2nd Team
Baseball Doug Mayo 1995 1995 NAIA Honorable Mention 
M. Basketball John Wassenbergh 1995, 1996 1995 NAIA 3rd Team, 1996 NAIA 2nd Team All-American 
Softball Kellee Murphy 1996 1996 NAIA All-American 
M. Basketball Kyle Sewer 1997 1997 NAIA Third Team
M. Basketball Carl Howell 1997, 1998, 1999 1997 NAIA Honorable Mention, 1998 NAIA 2nd Team, 1996 NAIA 1st Team
M. Soccer Michael Bolanz 1998  
Baseball David Quintal 1999  
Baseball Steve Osborne 1999, 2000, 2001 1999 NAIA Hon. Mention, 2000 NAIA Hon. Mention, 2001 NAIA Hon. Mention 
Baseball Jesse LaCasse 2000 2000 NAIA Honorable Mention 
W. Basketball Stacey Gelinas 2001 2001 Kodak All-American
W. Basketball Sue Picard 2001 2001 Kodak All-American
M. Soccer Jesse Beer 2001  
M. Basketball C.J. Vose 2001 2001 NAIA Honorable Mention, 2002 NAIA Honorable Mention 
Baseball Brent Dan 2001 2001 NAIA Honorable Mention 
M. Basketball Bilal Dawan-Abdullah 2002 2002 NAIA Honorable Mention 
Baseball Charlie Furbush 2006 NCAA DIII 2nd Team All-American 
Baseball Luke Enman 2007 2007 D3baseball.com 2nd Team
Baseball Ian Lee 2009 2009 D3baseball.com Honorable Mention 
Baseball Pat Moran 2009 2009 D3baseball.com Honorable Mention 
Baseball Todd Keneborus (2) 2010 2010 ABCA/Rawlings 3rd Team, 2010 D3Baseball.com 3rd Team
Field Hockey Meaghan Johnson 2011 2011 Longstreth/NFHCA 3rd Team
Baseball Chad Rafferty (2) 2012 2012 ABCA/Rawlings NCAA Division III 3rd Team, 2012 D3Baseball 3rd Team
M. Soccer Dalton Gaumer (2) 2017, 2018 2017 U.S.C. 3rd Team, 2017 D3soccer.com 3rd Team, 2018 U.S.C. 3rd Team
M. Soccer Blake Mullen 2017, 2018 2017 D3soccer.com 2nd Team, 2018 D3soccer.com 2nd Team
Field Hockey Libby Pomerleau 2018, 2019 2018 Synapse Sports 3rd Team , 2019 Synapse Sports 3rd Team 
W. Basketball Kelsi McNamara (2) 2019 2019 D3hoops.com 3rd Team, 2019 WBCA Honorable Mention
Baseball Joey Murphy 2019 2019 D3baseball.com Fourth Team 
W. Basketball Cassandra Stapelfeld 2022 2022 Women's Basketball Coaches Association (WBCA) Honorable Mention

 

 

Michael Bolanz '00
John Alexander '74 Jesse Beer '02 George Bockus '88 Michael Bolanz '99 Danielle Bouchard '95 
 
Carolyn Brooks '88 Kendra Coates '91 Greg Collymore '93 Jeff Creech '86 Brent Dan '02
Bilal Dawan-Abdullah '02 Luke Enman '08 Kevin Fitzgerald '88 Charlie Furbush '06 Dalton Gaumer '19
Stacey Gelinas '02 Jamie Header '93 Karen Heslin '96 Carl Howell '99 Meaghan Johnson '12
 
Mike Johnston '74 Todd Keneborus '11 Jesse LaCasse '03 Ian Lee '11 Doug Mayo '96
Kelsi McNamara '19 Pat Moran '10 Bill Mucci '87 Blake Mullen '19 Kellee Murphy '96
 
Joey Murphy '19 Steve Osborne '01 Sue Picard '02 Arlo Pike '86 Libby Pomerleau '20
David Quintal '99 Chad Rafferty '13 Leon Renaud '92 Sharon Rines '94 Steve Schuler '94
 
Kyle Sewer '97 C.J. Vose '03 John Wassenburgh '96 Dani Waterman '94 Kelly Wood '93