DATE | YEAR | WON | SCORE | LOST | LOCATION | SJC Leader | USM Leader |
Feb. 14 | 1990 | Southern Maine | 97-86 | Saint Joseph's | Portland Expo | Chase, 25 | Bonsant, 33 |
Feb. 13 | 1991 | Saint Joseph's | 91-77 | Southern Maine | Portland Expo | Collymore, 24 | Bonsant, 18 |
Feb. 12 | 1992 | Southern Maine | 92-86 | Saint Joseph's | Currier Gymnasium | Chase, 20 | Cawley, 24 |
Feb. 10 | 1993 | Saint Joseph's | 92-75 | Southern Maine | Portland Expo | Chase, 17 | Laprise, 19 |
Feb. 9 | 1994 | Saint Joseph's | 75-67 | Southern Maine | Portland Expo | Wassenbergh, 24 | Tatro, 19 |
Feb. 8 | 1995 | Southern Maine | 77-64 | Saint Joseph's | Portland Expo | Campbell, 19 | Marcotte, 16 |
Feb. 7 | 1996 | Saint Joseph's | 94-77 | Southern Maine | Portland Expo | Wassenbergh, 28 | Tredwell, 19 |
Feb. 12 | 1997 | Saint Joseph's | 60-58 | Southern Maine | Portland Expo | Howell, 22 | Foster, 17 |
Feb. 4 | 1998 | Saint Joseph's | 59-57 | Southern Maine | Portland Expo | Howell, 18 | Cole, 17 |
Feb. 3 | 1999 | Saint Joseph's | 75-65 | Southern Maine | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Howell, 23 | Fennessey, 24 |
Feb. 2 | 2000 | Saint Joseph's | 78-71 | Southern Maine | Harold Alfond Center | Vose, 32 | Fennessey, 31 |
Jan. 31 | 2001 | Southern Maine | 101-72 | Saint Joseph's | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Gore, 19 | Millet, 23 |
Jan. 30 | 2002 | Southern Maine | 92-88 | Saint Joseph's | Harold Alfond Center | Dawan-Abdullah, 28 | Lovely/St. Pierre, 18 |
Feb. 5 | 2003 | Saint Joseph's | 106-92 | Southern Maine | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Stewart, 21 | Levecque, 30 |
Feb. 4 | 2004 | Southern Maine | 64-53 | Saint Joseph's | Harold Alfond Center | Monteiro, 18 | Francoeur, 17 |
Feb. 2 | 2005 | Southern Maine | 83-69 | Saint Joseph's | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Pratt, 23 | Levecque, 19 |
Feb. 1 | 2006 | Southern Maine | 60-54 | Saint Joseph's | Harold Alfond Center | Ouellet, 14 | Hardwick, 13 |
Jan. 30 | 2007 | Saint Joseph's | 80-58 | Southern Maine | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Alexander, 19 | Gabriele, 10 |
Jan. 24 | 2008 | Southern Maine | 71-69 | Saint Joseph's | Harold Alfond Center | Rue/Eatmon, 17 | Whitaker, 16 |
Nov. 30 | 2008 | Saint Joseph's | 72-55 | Southern Maine | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | O'Brien, 18 | Smith, 17 |
Nov. 29 | 2009 | Saint Joseph's | 73-61 | Southern Maine | Harold Alfond Center | O'Brien, 24 | Isaac, 35 |
Nov. 28 | 2010 | Saint Joseph's | 81-75 | Southern Maine | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Kelley, 27 | Isaac, 27 |
Nov. 27 | 2011 | Saint Joseph's | 61-59 OT | Southern Maine | Harold Alfond Center | O'Brien, 21 | Pagentine, 17 |
Nov. 25 | 2012 | Saint Joseph's | 70-56 | Southern Maine | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Simonds, 15 | Sullivan, 18 |
Dec. 1 | 2013 | Southern Maine | 65-60 | Saint Joseph's | Harold Alfond Center | Jobin, 23 | Sullivan, 19 |
Nov. 30 | 2014 | Southern Maine | 74-58 | Saint Joseph's | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Simonds, 20 | Littlefield, 29 |
Nov. 29 | 2015 | Saint Joseph's | 71-66 | Southern Maine | Harold Alfond Center | Crawley, 19 | Libby, 18 |
Nov. 27 | 2016 | Southern Maine | 74-72 | Saint Joseph's | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Berry, 19 | Leal, 23 |
Nov. 26 | 2017 | Saint Joseph's | 59-53 | Southern Maine | Harold Alfond Center | Berry/Mileikis, 11 | McCue, 13 |
Nov. 25 | 2018 | Saint Joseph's | 83-79 | Southern Maine | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Casale, 22 | Pitts-Young/McCue, 20 |
Dec. 1 | 2019 | Southern Maine | 98-91 | Saint Joseph's | Harold Alfond Center | Casale, 33 | J. Thomas, 38 |
Nov. 28 | 2021 | Southern Maine | 86-74 | Saint Joseph's | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Llopiz, 18 | Dixon, 32 |
Dec. 30 | 2022 | Saint Joseph's | 75-52 | Southern Maine | Harold Alfond Center | Foley, 15 | Whelan, 12 |
Nov. 15 | 2023 | Southern Maine | 79-66 | Saint Joseph's | Warren G. Hill Gymnasium | Wani, 13 | Whelan/Dixon, 18 |
Costello Cup Record: Saint Joseph's 19-15
Category | # | Team | Date |
Most Points: | 106 | Saint Joseph's | 2/5/2003 |
Fewest Points: | 53 | Southern Maine | 2/4/2004 |
Most Points - Loss: | 92 | Southern Maine | 2/5/2003 |
Fewest Points - Win: | 59 | Saint Joseph's | 2/4/1998 |
Largest Winning Margin: | 29 | USM, 101-72 | 1/31/2001 |
Closest Winning Margin: | 2 - 5x, most recently | USM, 74-72 | 11/27/2016 |
Highest Scorer (Saint Joseph's): | Casale - 33 | 12/1/2019 | |
Highest Scorer (USM): | J. Thomas - 38 | 12/1/2019 | |
Longest Winning Streak: | 5 | Saint Joseph's | Twice |