DATE	YEAR	WON	SCORE	LOST	LOCATION	SJC Leader	USM Leader
Feb. 14	1990	Southern Maine	97-86	Saint Joseph's	Portland Expo	Chase, 25	Bonsant, 33
Feb. 13	1991	Saint Joseph's	91-77	Southern Maine	Portland Expo	Collymore, 24	Bonsant, 18
Feb. 12	1992	Southern Maine	92-86	Saint Joseph's	Currier Gymnasium	Chase, 20	Cawley, 24
Feb. 10	1993	Saint Joseph's	92-75	Southern Maine	Portland Expo	Chase, 17	Laprise, 19
Feb. 9	1994	Saint Joseph's	75-67	Southern Maine	Portland Expo	Wassenbergh, 24	Tatro, 19
Feb. 8	1995	Southern Maine	77-64	Saint Joseph's	Portland Expo	Campbell, 19	Marcotte, 16
Feb. 7	1996	Saint Joseph's	94-77	Southern Maine	Portland Expo	Wassenbergh, 28	Tredwell, 19
Feb. 12	1997	Saint Joseph's	60-58	Southern Maine	Portland Expo	Howell, 22	Foster, 17
Feb. 4	1998	Saint Joseph's	59-57	Southern Maine	Portland Expo	Howell, 18	Cole, 17
Feb. 3	1999	Saint Joseph's	75-65	Southern Maine	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Howell, 23	Fennessey, 24
Feb. 2	2000	Saint Joseph's	78-71	Southern Maine	Harold Alfond Center	Vose, 32	Fennessey, 31
Jan. 31	2001	Southern Maine	101-72	Saint Joseph's	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Gore, 19	Millet, 23
Jan. 30	2002	Southern Maine	92-88	Saint Joseph's	Harold Alfond Center	Dawan-Abdullah, 28	Lovely/St. Pierre, 18
Feb. 5	2003	Saint Joseph's	106-92	Southern Maine	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Stewart, 21	Levecque, 30
Feb. 4	2004	Southern Maine	64-53	Saint Joseph's	Harold Alfond Center	Monteiro, 18	Francoeur, 17
Feb. 2	2005	Southern Maine	83-69	Saint Joseph's	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Pratt, 23	Levecque, 19
Feb. 1	2006	Southern Maine	60-54	Saint Joseph's	Harold Alfond Center	Ouellet, 14	Hardwick, 13
Jan. 30	2007	Saint Joseph's	80-58	Southern Maine	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Alexander, 19	Gabriele, 10
Jan. 24	2008	Southern Maine	71-69	Saint Joseph's	Harold Alfond Center	Rue/Eatmon, 17	Whitaker, 16
Nov. 30	2008	Saint Joseph's	72-55	Southern Maine	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	O'Brien, 18	Smith, 17
Nov. 29	2009	Saint Joseph's	73-61	Southern Maine	Harold Alfond Center	O'Brien, 24	Isaac, 35
Nov. 28	2010	Saint Joseph's	81-75	Southern Maine	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Kelley, 27	Isaac, 27
Nov. 27	2011	Saint Joseph's	61-59 OT	Southern Maine	Harold Alfond Center	O'Brien, 21	Pagentine, 17
Nov. 25	2012	Saint Joseph's	70-56	Southern Maine	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Simonds, 15	Sullivan, 18
Dec. 1	2013	Southern Maine	65-60	Saint Joseph's	Harold Alfond Center	Jobin, 23	Sullivan, 19
Nov. 30	2014	Southern Maine	74-58	Saint Joseph's	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Simonds, 20	Littlefield, 29
Nov. 29	2015	Saint Joseph's	71-66	Southern Maine	Harold Alfond Center	Crawley, 19	Libby, 18
Nov. 27	2016	Southern Maine	74-72	Saint Joseph's	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Berry, 19	Leal, 23
Nov. 26	2017	Saint Joseph's	59-53	Southern Maine	Harold Alfond Center	Berry/Mileikis, 11	McCue, 13
Nov. 25	2018	Saint Joseph's	83-79	Southern Maine	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Casale, 22	Pitts-Young/McCue, 20
Dec. 1	2019	Southern Maine	98-91	Saint Joseph's	Harold Alfond Center	Casale, 33	J. Thomas, 38
Nov. 28	2021	Southern Maine	86-74	Saint Joseph's	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Llopiz, 18	Dixon, 32
Dec. 30	2022	Saint Joseph's	75-52	Southern Maine	Harold Alfond Center	Foley, 15	Whelan, 12
Nov. 15	2023	Southern Maine	79-66	Saint Joseph's	Warren G. Hill Gymnasium	Wani, 13	Whelan/Dixon, 18

 

Costello Cup Record: Saint Joseph's 19-15

Category	#	Team	Date
Most Points:	106	Saint Joseph's	2/5/2003
Fewest Points:	53	Southern Maine	2/4/2004
Most Points - Loss:	92	Southern Maine	2/5/2003
Fewest Points - Win:	59	Saint Joseph's	2/4/1998
Largest Winning Margin:	29	USM, 101-72	1/31/2001
Closest Winning Margin:	2 - 5x, most recently	USM, 74-72	11/27/2016
Highest Scorer (Saint Joseph's):	Casale - 33		12/1/2019
Highest Scorer (USM):	J. Thomas - 38		12/1/2019
Longest Winning Streak:	5	Saint Joseph's	Twice