Date Year WON SCORE LOST Location SJC Leader USM Leader
Feb. 14 1990 Southern Maine 96-82 Saint Joseph's Portland Expo L'Heureux, 21 Pate, 26
Feb. 13 1991 Southern Maine 78-75 Saint Joseph's Portland Expo Coates, 18 Pate, 36
Feb. 12 1992 Southern Maine 81-65 Saint Joseph's Portland Expo Bourget, 22 Pulkkinen, 25
Feb. 10 1993 Saint Joseph's 66-64 Southern Maine Portland Expo Rines, 19 Gagnon, 19
Feb. 9 1994 Saint Joseph's 72-53 Southern Maine Portland Expo Rines, 29 Struck, 10
Feb. 8 1995 Saint Joseph's 61-60 Southern Maine Portland Expo Bouchard, 22 Brown, 16
Feb. 7 1996 Southern Maine 80-59 Saint Joseph's Portland Expo Marquis, 14 Brown, 17
Feb. 12 1997 Southern Maine 100-54 Saint Joseph's Portland Expo Field, 18 Brown, 27
Feb. 2 1998 Southern Maine 73-51 Saint Joseph's Portland Expo Burrell, 9 Libby, 18
Feb. 3 1999 Southern Maine 70-44 Saint Joseph's Warren G. Hill Gymnasium  Gelinas/Field, 7 Libby, 20
Feb. 2 2000 Southern Maine 61-54 Saint Joseph's Harold Alfond Center  Gelinas, 25 Plant, 24
Jan. 31 2001 Southern Maine 66-54 Saint Joseph's Warren G. Hill Gymnasium  Rice/Picard, 14 Kimball, 18
Feb.2 2002 Southern Maine 62-58 Saint Joseph's Harold Alfond Center  Rice, 15 Cressler, 14
Feb. 5 2003 Southern Maine 77-54 Saint Joseph's Warren G. Hill Gymnasium  Rice, 23 Jones, 19
Feb. 4 2004 Southern Maine 80-54 Saint Joseph's Harold Alfond Center  Rice, 19 Jones, 18
Feb. 2 2005 Southern Maine 79-45 Saint Joseph's Warren G. Hill Gymnasium  Dumais, 14 Myles/Frost, 14
Feb. 16 2006 Southern Maine 75-25 Saint Joseph's Harold Alfond Center  Regula/Ludwig, 6 Myles, 14
Nov. 29 2009 Southern Maine 67-50 Saint Joseph's Harold Alfond Center  Freeman, 12 Leighton, 20
Nov. 28 2010 Southern Maine 70-48 Saint Joseph's Warren G. Hill Gymnasium  Geel, 11 Cochran, 15
Nov. 27 2011 Saint Joseph's 67-62 OT Southern Maine Harold Alfond Center  Parent, 16 Cochran, 23
Nov. 25 2012 Southern Maine 67-52 Saint Joseph's Warren G. Hill Gymnasium  Shufelt/Assante, 10 4 players w/ 12
Dec. 1 2013 Southern Maine 60-49 Saint Joseph's Harold Alfond Center  Moore, 13 Pelletier/Callender, 14
Nov. 30 2014 Southern Maine 65-57 OT Saint Joseph's Warren G. Hill Gymnasium  Cahill, 22 Ramonas, 18
Nov. 29 2015 Saint Joseph's 74-67 Southern Maine Harold Alfond Center  McNamara, 35 Pelletier, 18
Nov. 27 2016 Saint Joseph's 67-63 Southern Maine Warren G. Hill Gymnasium  Benway, 22 Stacy, 15
Nov. 26 2017 Saint Joseph's 69-41 Southern Maine Harold Alfond Center  Champagne, 19 Nicholson, 10
Nov. 25 2018 Saint Joseph's 71-51 Southern Maine Warren G. Hill Gymnasium McNamara, 37 Luckhardt, 14
Dec. 1 2019 Saint Joseph's 67-65 Southern Maine Harold Alfond Center Walsh, 18 Luckhardt, 18
Nov. 28 2021 Saint Joseph's 62-52 Southern Maine Warren G. Hill Gymnasium Hurley, 21 Harris, 17
Nov. 27 2022 Saint Joseph's 58-42 Southern Maine Harold Alfond Center Hurley, 16 Fleming, 13
Nov. 26 2023 Saint Joseph's 53-52 Southern Maine Warren G. Hill Gymnasium E. Stapelfeld, 13 Ramsdell, 17

 

COSTELLO CUP RECORD: SAINT JOSEPH'S 12-19

Category # Team Date
Most Points: 100 Southern Maine 2/12/1996
Fewest Points: 25 Saint Joseph's 2/16/2006
Most Points - Loss: 82 Saint Joseph's 2/14/1990
Fewest Points - Win: 53 Saint Joseph's 11/26/2023
Largest Winning Margin: 50 USM, 75-25 2/16/2006
Closest Winning Margin: 1 Twice 2/8/95 & 11/26/23
Highest Scorer (Saint Joseph's): McNamara - 37 Saint Joseph's, 71-51 11/25/2018
Highest Scorer (USM): Pate - 36 USM, 78-75 2/13/1991
Longest Winning Streak: 13 USM 1996-2010