The first men's lacrosse player to enter the SJC Athletics Hall of Fame, Horgan was a dynamic athlete for the Monks during their first years as an NCAA DIII varsity program

Horgan graduated in 2012 as the Monks' career leader in goals (111), assists (67) and points (178) – despite having missed his sophomore season due to injury – and remains among the leaders in each category at the time of his induction

The two-time First Team All-Conference selection was the first St. Joe's men's lacrosse player to garner ECAC All-New England and NEILA Senior All-Star Game recognition

Remarkably consistent, Horgan tallied at least 54 points in each of his three seasons and helped the Monks advance to the postseason all three years, including 2011 when they notched the first playoff victory in program history